Ending Wars Justly
by
David K. Chan (Editor)
ISBN: 9781003454144
Publication Date: April 14, 2025
Professor Yvonne Chiu of the College of Distance Education wrote Chapter : "Beginning the End: Unilateral vs. Collaborative Conceptions of War Termination". You can request a copy of the book via interlibrary loan or a purchase request, just log in with your CAC or War College Blackboard credentials.
The ethic of cooperation in warfare helps belligerents end wars with a greater likelihood of sustainable peace, but there are trade-offs and lingering questions, and moral expectations for cooperation can be exploited. The importance of cooperation in war points to a conceptual shortcoming of the jus ex bello literature, which approaches war from a unilateral perspective. More so than ethical evaluations of other stages of war (e.g., jus ad bellum and jus in bello), the ethics of ending war (jus ex bello) requires taking into account the interactive nature of warfare, which has not only practical but also ethical implications.
Ending a war is as much, if not even more, of an ethical ordeal as starting one, and practitioners and philosophers alike devote insufficient attention to its challenges. Large-scale conventional wars call attention to every aspect of warfare, including the importance of war termination, that low-intensity conflicts—such as the “forever wars” of recent memory, especially Afghanistan and Vietnam—do not. Ending these different types of wars, however, is equally—though differently—complicated, but in all cases, the need for the defeated party to acquiesce to its loss is too often overlooked.
The ethic of cooperation in warfare helps belligerents end wars with a greater likelihood of sustainable peace, but there are trade-offs and lingering questions. On the surface, cooperation between enemies is essential to end the war—after all, both sides have to agree to lay down arms, whatever the terms are—but the role of cooperation in war termination runs more deeply still and presents its own challenges and dilemmas. The importance of cooperation in war points to a conceptual shortcoming of the jus ex bello literature, which approaches war termination from a unilateral perspective, making it impossible to sustain even if it can be initially implemented. More so than ethical evaluations of other stages of war (e.g., jus ad bellum and jus in bello), the ethics of ending war (jus ex bello) requires taking into account the interactive nature of warfare, which has not only practical but ethical implications.